Worksheet 5: Physician agency and fixed prices

Assume $B (x) = 4 x^{1 / 2}$ , $N B^{0} = 0$ , anc $c = 1$ . Further assume that prices are fixed administratively at, $\bar{p} = 2$ . Note that, in this case, we work only off of the patient’s net benefit constraint.

Question 1:

What is the physician’s and patient’s optimal amount of care provided?

The physician maximizes profit, $π = p x - c x$ , subject to the constraint, $4 x^{1 / 2} = p x$ . Since $p$ is fixed, the physician simply sets $x$ as high as possible, which means they set $x$ to the point where the constraint binds. With $p = 2$ , this means $4 x^{1 / 2} = 2 x$ , and solving for $x$ means $16 x = 4 x^{2} ⟶ 16 = 4 x ⟶ x = 4$ .

The patient cares about maximizing net benefit, $4 x^{1 / 2} - 2 x$ . This is maximized at $x$ such that $2 x^{- 1 / 2} - 2 = 0 ⟶ x = 1$ .

Question 2:

The government is considering increasing the price to $\bar{p} = 3$ . What are the new optimal levels of care for physicians and patients at this new price?

At this new price, the physician would choose $x$ such that $4 x^{1 / 2} = 3 x ⟶ 16 x = 9 x^{2} ⟶ 16 = 9 x ⟶ x = \frac{16}{9}$ . The patient would choose $x$ such that $2 x^{- 1 / 2} - 3 = 0 ⟶ x = 4 / 9$ .

Question 3:

How would the price change affect the difference between the patient and physician’s optimal amounts?

First, note that the amount of care decreases as the administrative price increases (opposite of the standard supply curve). Similarly, the deviation between the patient and physician optimal amounts decreases.